wait wait wait.. is that last picture what your coat looks like now?? its like.., completely beige..
because I have some areas on mine (assuming its a middle ground between the early versions and what he does now) where there are areas of slight discoloration.. parts where it looks a little brownish.. or rust like.. initially, I thought maybe that one time I washed it.., maybe there was some left over bleach in the washing machine at the time? idk.. its very very subtle though.. you'd have to take a really hard look to notice it on mine..
I would say the fit and thickness of the coat is my biggest gripe.. mine fits me so well from a visual point.. it looks tightly tailored to me which is great.., IF the coat was thick enough on its own.. because it isn't,, I would need to layer up underneath.., but its so form fitting, I can't layer too many more shirts and sweatshirts underneath it.. and that's the drawback for me personally..
I'd consider getting another one.. but everything would need to be perfect.. and i'd rather have something laminated like our guy Countlau has sought out.. I know actual waxing is more screen accurate.., but I'd rather not have to deal with wax at all if possible..
If I could still get that leather-like shine.., without my coat being sticky and having all that stuff on it, that's what I would like to have..
so as of now.., if and when I get another.., I'm still going SR.. clearly use a better material and that material is finished well with a great color..
their only foul up for me,, is the fur material ( needs to look more coarse) and the price obviously is pretty intense..
I've heard they're warm... but i really don't know.. they appear thin to me.. but maybe that lamination makes it feel much more insulated.. I will say, since waxing mine.., its much heavier.. and handles wind much better..
the WLS looks a great deal thicker just through photos alone.. same with Magnolia.. as thin as my BEP coat is.. the newer photos of his latest version does appear thicker as well..
I think if Jameel takes up Countlau's suggestions.., we'd probably end up with the pinnacle coat.. especially with lamination. ideas.. and if he could get that almost teal color Countlau had.. hot damn!
I still have to run a second coat of Barbour so its more uniform.. BUT after rubbing the coat down with my fingertips.. all in downward motions.., my coat went from looking fuzzy to slick/wet.. bringing out some shine.. so i was really glad to see that.. I still have to trim some fur around the neckline though.. it isn't flush enough with the collar and that makes it look less pleasing to the eye.. and not as SA..
I'm VERY happy with my fur color now though.. if you were to see it in person, it's like the perfect hue.. a huge improvement from the yellowish beige it was initially. only.., I can't get both my lapels to lay the same.. the right one sits perfectly in place.., but the right one (that's connected to the face-covering extension.. that doesn't like to stay in place,, extended/winged out when open/folded over.. i know the design isn't meant to be perfectly symmetrical... but I wanted the lapel to look close at least... i think if they were a big bigger.., it wouldn't have been a problem..
Hi Toni,
I'll give my views, if it'd be useful:
- beige is a nice color, but I asked
Patattack since I can't understand how inner side of the collar kept the original color and how it has been washed and/or used, however, I guess it's not what we need, but another open secret of the day, is that I managed to resurrect my coat from my mad experiments using (after discoloured in diluted bleach 3hrs bath mild water and washer cycle with color remover) rit 4 synthetics teal+grey+ the qty was enough to recommended dose for a coat,but I added also classic powder dye (italian brand but it's the same u could find as dylon or whatever) since from my little experience, it is very consistent to add the needed concentration of the dye, so it will work for sure also with uncoated duck, even better, but you have to consider that if you waxed it and you'll ever have a need to such a processing, you must remove the wax somehow before (and with a lighter wax, I managed to do it once washing it 90° in the washer with another full cotton garment, but it's a procedure that would completely mess up the lining, so I know perhaps it is also possible by re-heating it and brushing with sponges, but not sure about that I'm not that expert)
- the lining, if inconsistent or already compromised, you should evaluate if the polyester is still good, if not, it needs a radical (and expensive, demanding work) change by replacing it all, or if you could keep it, you could strenghten with non-woven or artificial wool to be sewed onto it, but if you exceed with that, you risk to mess with the size which couldn't fit you any more
- about SR you got me, but it was not that secret, open or not, that from a while I was reconsidering their cloth as the best available, even if not a duck weave, but after you have the details of a coat like Jameel's (which however no longer seems to me to be able to provide useful feedback for further improvement, and in any case I couldn't blame him on the issue of the correct cloth because he had already made it clear in the past what problems there are in gettin'it from the manufacturer as requested), to then have the same design of the rounded seams, and a collar, which although mine is too short on the upper side, has the right shapes, you will have to end up trying your hand at what I I seemed to understand that you didn't want it initially (tweaking and tailor interventions), because the SR as it arrives will also be terrific with a high-end look etc, but it doesn't have these SA details, so maybe you should then spend even more and end up at a tailor
- if you do distress the rite way, that fur is still too yellow, but it comes out well, as you stated, the problem will be it deteriorates if you'll undergo procedures as the previously described: washing cycles and/or other dyes touch-up, make the fleeces broken quickly, and I'm believing is about all types of fake fur, I didn't understand what concerns real shearling SR put in their jackets cause he wrote is more of a solid solution but, I found a square for that with my new fur, I have enough for another coat, but I'd have replaced anyway even with a cheaper and weaker one, if I had a SR to tweak
I would also add that the girl who replied to me from SR had no problem admitting that the fabric is NOT waterproof, in fact if I ever contradict myself and get one, a lot of work awaits me, but also a bath in the light nikwax at least to give a bit of dwr (nothing compromising, without even using a washing machine which, however, according to the label, can be done on a delicate cycle on SR).
Anyway now I will finish mine as best as possible, but I understand that it won't be able to reach with this the level I was aiming for and that it would be possible, without talking about being a perfect copy of the movie one which I understand is not ponderable, but I'll be waiting for some time , if better solutions don't arrive, I think it's now clear to everyone here that I'm not kinda guy who stops until I've gotten what I wanted, although I can reduce my demands, but not on things that common sense still deems improvable, so you can imagine how it will end.
About waxing, there's a little to say: Mechanismo found very SA way to fix the shine without exceeding, rainproofing a bit, and add cold protection, but the handling especially of selfmade waxed (but also native) is what it is, and we deduce that, as nor all duck clothes neither twill clothes are the same thickness and behaviour, maybe waxing a bep didn't fit as much right as waxing a wsl.
About cold protection, I can confirm that now my laminated has just an imperceptible layer left, it was that one which was make me feel good even with low-temp, figuring out that all my questionable attempts with coating didn't end up as I wanted, I'll fix it by adding quiliting sewed to my great polyester lining, but if the wax wasn't enough/not spread rite way or simply not that suitable for bep duck...dunno, I guess that's the reason why