The problem is.., your coat was already perfect the way it was.. I wouldn't have touched it.. it had a shiny emerald color but also the teal hues.. the teal is what made it really stand out.. I would have just left it,, with that leather looking shine
as I wrote, that teal color wasn't stable and too light, it would have fade away badly at first wash, so I said I was waiting the medium to fix it...but no acrylic medium (and not even paint) seems to fix the hue long-lasting and properly, on this cloth.
Many months ago I tried bleach on a little piece I obtained when I changed the lining, the result was about nothing even pure bleach, but now I figure out that the inner side (full black and not the same grey effect from outside) is not PU laminated (the PU layer must have been fixed by machine melting it on the visible side), and the high amount of wash cycles I've done together with dyeing procedures etc, have made it slightly lighter, then since it's basically cotton, now that I finished cleaning all streaks and peels and it about to be fully recovered in the original dark tone in kinda distressed good look, I'm willing (and already doing) my very last move: bleach again (not pure and ponderated under my constant supervision to stop any exceeding in tryng to lighten that grey: by insisting, the inner is now more clear towards a middle green-brownish hue than the original black, so the aim of my game, is trying to reach an even lighter tone no matter which one, without having it too clear as in my previous fail with grey. If it won't work (as it seems from outside, where everything is about the same before), I have about the same original coat, but with no major damages (very lucky me) and a nice distressed look and a very little lightened tone. But if it works, I know what is needed for re-fix the hue perfectly, and it would be one of the simplest method to dye cotton: very simple pre-made washing machine dyes, which have never disappointed in those cases where the bleach had been successful, I saw many times that what bleach can lighten, those dyes can fix, and in that case I'll put a massive dose to be sure have some good effect, and I've no fear in too much other distressing or messing with the coat again with that.
my last thought about the situation will be the same:
- Jameel got the SA design with very few tweaks to go (if size and proportions are suitable to the customer, never possible to take for granted without make adjustments in person, but I would say with anyone, and often in person too)
- wsl best value for money considering the material quality
- SR only has a quality laminate with a slightly too bluish hue which in any case is the closest to the film, but it is really little for that price if everything else, no matter how much quality there is, makes those who really want k's coat smile.
So, there is little to go around: still, there is no one who has fully hit the mark, and for what after years it is clearly possible to find and obtain even by insisting and putting a lot of effort into it, at this point I wouldn't say it's worth the effort.
It's worth spending who knows how much on K's coat, if there's always some gap when you look at it better?
From a purely pragmatic point of view, you might as well have a coat that can possibly withstand almost a little rain, therefore laminated or waxed, but personally I trust the first one more for obvious reasons, otherwise I wouldn't have chosen it, it must be said that I have recently created an experimental hat in nylon mixed with denim, rainproof, which resembles the hat worn by replicants when they come out of production but more stylish and less hospital-type (suitable to be worn without becoming ridiculous), to be combined with the coat completing it in case rain occurs, hoping not to have compromised the lamination too much, I'll find out (I had a hood that I posted a long time ago, but with the style this move is more successful, even if k has never put stuff like this in his head).
So, in summary, if I could go back I would repeat this purchase.
The choice of a wsl is also not bad (it's worth it and at least you spend less, but you have to be able to fix it since in the end they don't do much on the details, otherwise it will cost you quite a bit to do as well), or of a discounted bep like yours, which however I don't think has any rainproof properties.
SR, Magnoli and stuff to spend almost double what I spent or triple/quadruple what you spent, frankly I see it to be left alone, because in the end there isn't all this improvement for the things that matter more, and the coat you get from it stays as distant from the film if not more.
If one day by chance I find a suitable fabric, and I still have the time to waste on it that I have now (very difficult), based on the design of the one I have from Jameel, I will make one myself, perhaps with help, and thus closing the question fully satisfied, otherwise that's fine as now.