That is not true. Canon on the series identifies the fact that they were functional/removable. As such, it is a replica of what would have been found in-universe - NOT a replica of the prop. And the former is what TWC *claims* to be creating. But, as essentially everyone has admitted, this color palette is not one found in the Starfleet world. THAT takes this out of the "replica" category. And the primary colors they are using are those found on LEGOS and most other *young* kids toys. So, yes, that fact shifts this towards the toy category - the same way having to paint orange on the end of a blaster makes the item look like a toy and NOT a replica.
Orange is simply NOT part of the weapon's color palette - the same way these colors are NOT part of the Starfleet color palette.
Put simply, TWC goes on and on about how it is trying to get every tiny detail correct - from the patterning on the case, to the texture of the metal screen in the hood, to the logos used on the screen, etc. Heck, for things that they HAD to do but we would hardly ever see - like the reinforcing patterns inside the tricorder frame - they took the hexagonal shapes that we see used BY Starfleet and used them for that functional design. But they didn't do that here. This color palette is NOT used by Starfleet in TOS - not even close - any more than the Discovery logo was used in TOS.
These colors jump the shark in a *big* way.
Now, you are certainly free to NOT to care if they don't use the right logos or colors from TOS. Many of their customers wouldn't even *notice* such things. But *intentionally* choosing things they KNOW are not from TOS *definitely* removes TWC's work from the category they WISH the tricorder to be in.
And I, for one, am *indeed* BUMMED by that fact - especially after all the work they put into things being SO accurate in OTHER areas. IF these are indeed the colors TWC are using, then this feels like an unforced error on their part - a *big* one.
And, if AnubisGuard is right, it's one we will NOT be *able* to correct.
Apology accepted. Heat of the moment. I understand.