pics shown by propstore, are the best I've ever seen to get ideas, I would advise the most capable producers (namely Indy and Jameel, since SR and WSL don't seem to listen, I hope for their sake I'm wrong), to duly re-evaluate how useful it is based on what is more than evident now.
First of all, the shirt seems more bluish than the dark grey-black Theory one (which is fantastic), the gloves are the same as mine (real leather, a contradiction, unless in the end even animals can make synthetic ones like humans and tan their skins), the trousers are the easiest part I would say (one of the ones I have is practically identical), staying on topic, so on the coat:
- the colour is practically identical to the current condition of my SR, but as I said, it gives a more saturated light, surely given by the fact that it is duck, I would say waxed with a classic method (like Otter or waxes of that kind), I certainly wouldn't say native because they wrote in other articles about how "they had sent it to be waterproofed", so the SR gives a slightly different effect, this is perhaps given by an interlining used underneath on the fabric to make it more stable and full in appearance, which also gives that light piping effect that is surely a little less accentuated than mine with the shoelaces on the SR (which however was necessary as it is SR totally lacking that kind of support for the fabric, while Jameel has intelligently used foam as well as some thick interlining on the edges), so I would say that the methods seen are fine, for what it can be done from the position of a hobbyist, in fact they are very good; when it was said that it doesn't shine, I would say that there is a certain shine effect, my SR from the pics I can take, I would say that on that aspect it is practically on the same level, maybe even the less dark green that Indy uses, Jameel's duck (both waxed and unwaxed) instead seems too dry to me (maybe it could be improved by waxing it, if it doesn't darken too much), WSL no I would say just another type of green, even though we saw an excellent result by waxing it...probably I am also wrong to insist about a lighter color (not so dark as it was Jameel's laminated twill, but the other colors from k coat noticeable vendors, especially SR, seem to nail it)
- the collar in the end is much longer on the upper length, than any replica I have seen (even the SR, which I was able to modify precisely because it seems long to finish tight), on this no one seems to have understood well how much (much) longer that measurement must be to have that effect (the photos of it closed speak very clearly), maybe although the lapels and how the fur is sewn don't make sense to me, the only one who came close enough at least in the right proportions is Indy (Jameel's collar barely closes not only on mine I would say, the SR one is wrong, you have room to modify it, but anyway, as long as it is, it should be on that side, even more, WSL basically seems to me to give it on the tight side, then those who fight for it and also luck, maybe get it as they want, but with ifs and buts you don't get anywhere)
- the sleeves don't seem to be as tight as SR and WSL, it seems that they almost give Jameel reason to have left them wider, anyway apart from SA or not, on my SR they look very tight on me, it goes back to the discussion that if you are not Gosling with the exact arm that he had at that given moment, it will never fit you the same
- the precise shape of the cuffs, only Indy got it right, the other 3 are also fine, but it has a stylised curvature that in theory follows a certain precise model
- the edges on the bottom, which must be equal to the longitudinal length (exactly how I tweaked my coats), basically only Indy got them right, the others had a different edge (wider), furthermore it is quite taut, in fact my having tried to stiffening the SR (and succeeding, even if it already had a more composed setting compared to Jameel's coat) seems to me to give a really good effect, even Indy's coats go in that direction, and all in all, Jameel's ducks have a greater posture, it must be said that WSL seems in some cases quite solid and tight (which helps, but I see it slightly different), and SR can be ironed if desired (I did it after washing it as soon as I received it, then after the extra waxing and the various improvements, that's it)
- the fur seems to be a cross between the beautiful one I tracked from OVS and Jameel's super yellow one, then heavily worked on the distressing, I think I can see some signs of felting, I don't think it is exempt from ruining prematurely like the others, the effect is cool, however I don't regret having put the real shearling back on SR, it certainly lasts longer and after working it a bit, it still gives an excellent effect, so going a bit beyond the SA aspect
- there's no incremental cut at the bottom longer on the front or, if there is, very little (my two coats now have it, it's not that evident, that's fine with me anyway)
- the lines of the lapels and collar are pretty straight, not as curved as SR before I fixed it, and even those of other manufacturers, except maybe WSL, seem a bit too curved compared to here
- the setting of the double transverse waist seams of SR is too double-breasted, but I have to say that on me I can see them very well, I even increased it a bit when I fixed the eyelet and magnets, it makes it a bit more "neo" and less "k" (very tight at the sides of abdomen), but I can see them well, the eyelet as I said, is exactly the same as the one (at least on mine) that Jameel used, then it would be nice to try it and understand what real practical problems it would have by always using it
- the lining (2 inner pockets) is perhaps the best and closest to Indy, it doesn't seem super padded but still gives a great posture with some folds but without going overboard, especially the upper external corners under the shoulder panel, it seems that it is slightly superior to that of anyone I have seen producing replicas, and even by increasing the padding, I can't match the exact effect, maybe even a matter of shoulder panel measurements fine understanding
That said, well...in fact I don't know how much better I could have compared to my current SR...anyway as I was saying, here there is no scion of the moment, so I fear that I will settle, or I will continue to modify details on the coats forever (10k...), and it's mostly for collectors I'd say, since you cannot choose the size of course