Saw it yesterday. Overall, it’s a fun summer blockbuster, especially compared to the overhyped/over-marketed stuff it’s competing with (Jurassic World/Top Gun). I don’t buy the “this is the movie that Andy saw in 1995” thing because there is no way this is a movie from 1995. Take that out of the beginning and I don’t have a problem. But, as has been mentioned, there are plenty of anachronistic film elements, Marvel-esque “humor” where every possible moment is undercut with a non sequitur trying to pass as a joke, etc.
The film doesn’t fall completely flat due to these things, but they certainly stop it from feeling like a movie from 1995. Visually it’s stunning, one of Pixar’s best, which isn’t surprising, as technology ever marches forward. It was a fun genre film, which felt refreshing as most other Pixar films (barring Incredibles) fit into the unique category of “Pixar movie”. There were definitely moments in the film where I had a big dopey grin on my face. The secondary characters were mostly meh for me, with the exception being the robot cat Socks, who stole the show. Chris Evans does a good job. I felt that there could have been/should have been a Tim Allen cameo, but it’s no surprise to me that he would not have been invited back right now. In fact, this entire film may be partially an effort to distance a profitable character from an actor with extreme views.
Part of me wishes they’d used or made reference to either some of the Randy Newman score from the Toy Story movies or the theme song to the Buzz Lightyear TV show, which is very catchy. But that’s about the only reference to the TV show I would have wanted.